What happens if 3 teams tied for MLB Wild Card?

Last Modified Oct 2, 2024 09:57 GMT
What happens if 3 teams tied for MLB Wild Card?
MLB Wild Card 2023 Winner - Minnesota Twins

Major League Baseball (MLB) is a professional baseball league that ranks among the oldest major sports leagues in the United States and Canada. It comprises 30 teams organized into two leagues: the American League (AL) and the National League (NL), with each league further divided into three divisions, East, Central, and West.

The postseason format of MLB includes several series to identify the champions of each league. It kicks off with Wild Card games, first implemented in 1994 and later expanded in 2012 to allow more teams and expanded to 10 teams to playoffs. Four Wild Card teams from each league, the ones with the top records outside of division winners, compete against one another in a best-of-three series. Successful teams then progress to the Division Series, followed by the League Championship Series, culminating in the World Series where AL and NL champions face off in a best-of-seven matchup for championship.

MLB Wild Card three-team Tiebreaker rule

When three teams are tied for a Wild Card spot in Major League Baseball, teams are first assigned labels (A, B, and C) according to particular criteria. Team A competes against Team B in the opening match, with the victor earning the first Wild Card slot. The team that loses then plays against Team C, with the winner of this second matchup securing the last available Wild Card position. However, before these games can take place, the tiebreaker system needs to establish team designations based on various factors.

If all three teams have identical head-to-head records, the order is determined by:

  1. Highest winning percentage in intradivision games.

  2. Highest winning percentage in intraleague games.

  3. Highest winning percentage in the last half of intraleague games.

  4. Highest winning percentage in the last half plus one additional intraleague game. This method continues until a tie is broken, going back one game at a time as necessary.

If the three teams don’t have identical records against each other, the tiebreaker works differently:

  1. If one team has a better record against the other two combined, it advances.

  2. If no team has a superior record, the clubs are ranked by overall winning percentage against the other two. If two teams have identical percentages, the standard two-team tiebreaker rules apply. If all three still have identical percentages, the tie-breaking steps for identical head-to-head records are used again.

In cases where three teams tie for both a division title and a Wild Card spot, the division winner is determined first, and the two remaining teams use two-team tiebreaker rules to settle the Wild Card position. This process ensures an accurate and fair resolution for playoff qualification, even in complex scenarios.

MLB Wild Card four-team Tiebreaker rule

When four teams are tied for a single MLB Wild Card position, a series of tiebreakers is implemented to decide which team progresses. The initial step involves checking if one team has a better record against all three other teams. If such a team exists, it clinches the spot.

If no team stands out with a superior head-to-head record, the process shifts to overall performance in matches among the tied teams. Next, winning percentages from intradivision contests are assessed, followed by those from intraleague matchups. If the tie remains unbroken, MLB looks at the highest winning percentage in the last half of intraleague games.

Should further resolution be required, the tiebreaker extends to include the winning percentage in that last half and one additional intraleague game. This procedure continues by incrementally adding games until an ultimate decision is reached, ensuring a fair and comprehensive method to determine the Wild Card qualifier.

FAQs on MLB Wild Card

A. Each league (American and National) has four Wild Card teams, making a total of eight Wild Card teams competing in MLB.

A. The Wild Card series is a best-of-three format, with all games hosted by the higher-seeded team. The winners move on to the Division Series.

A. The MLB Wild Card was introduced in 1994 and expanded in 2012 to include more teams and add excitement to the postseason.

 A. Yes, several Wild Card teams have won the World Series, demonstrating that non-division winners can succeed in the playoffs and claim the championship.

Related Stories

MLB insider highlights Chipper Jones’ MVP season without All-Star honors as fresh snubs spark debate MLB insider highlights Chipper Jones’ MVP season without All-Star honors as fresh snubs spark debate
MLB insider highlights Chipper Jones’ MVP season without All-Star honors as fresh snubs spark debate
1d
MLB legend identifies 3 current sluggers with Barry Bonds-level fear factor ft. Aaron Judge MLB legend identifies 3 current sluggers with Barry Bonds-level fear factor ft. Aaron Judge
MLB legend identifies 3 current sluggers with Barry Bonds-level fear factor ft. Aaron Judge
“You’ll never see Aaron Judge do that” - MLB insiders predict Juan Soto’s lack of hustle will be major concern for Mets in long run “You’ll never see Aaron Judge do that” - MLB insiders predict Juan Soto’s lack of hustle will be major concern for Mets in long run
“You’ll never see Aaron Judge do that” - MLB insiders predict Juan Soto’s lack of hustle will be major concern for Mets in long run
Rangers vs. Astros: Game 2 prediction, lineups, odds, injuries, and picks - July 12, 2025 Rangers vs. Astros: Game 2 prediction, lineups, odds, injuries, and picks - July 12, 2025
Rangers vs. Astros: Game 2 prediction, lineups, odds, injuries, and picks - July 12, 2025
Is Ethan Holliday the next Corey Seager? In-depth breakdown of No. 1 prospect ahead of MLB Draft Is Ethan Holliday the next Corey Seager? In-depth breakdown of No. 1 prospect ahead of MLB Draft
Is Ethan Holliday the next Corey Seager? In-depth breakdown of No. 1 prospect ahead of MLB Draft 
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s wife Nathalie sends heartfelt message on 1,000th career hit vs. Athletics Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s wife Nathalie sends heartfelt message on 1,000th career hit vs. Athletics
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s wife Nathalie sends heartfelt message on 1,000th career hit vs. Athletics
"It's good to finally put a W on the board" - Shohei Ohtani opens up after leading Dodgers past Giants with flaming fastballs "It's good to finally put a W on the board" - Shohei Ohtani opens up after leading Dodgers past Giants with flaming fastballs
"It's good to finally put a W on the board" - Shohei Ohtani opens up after leading Dodgers past Giants with flaming fastballs
1d
“That’s f****** terrible” - Phillies' Trea Turner and Co. question All-Star Game with scathing review after Brewers’ Jacob Misiorowski nod “That’s f****** terrible” - Phillies' Trea Turner and Co. question All-Star Game with scathing review after Brewers’ Jacob Misiorowski nod
“That’s f****** terrible” - Phillies' Trea Turner and Co. question All-Star Game with scathing review after Brewers’ Jacob Misiorowski nod
1d
3 reasons why Padres should move on from Dylan Cease 3 reasons why Padres should move on from Dylan Cease
3 reasons why Padres should move on from Dylan Cease
"Way more deserving" - Justin Turner demands recognition for Cubs teammate Seiya Suzuki after All-Star snub "Way more deserving" - Justin Turner demands recognition for Cubs teammate Seiya Suzuki after All-Star snub
"Way more deserving" - Justin Turner demands recognition for Cubs teammate Seiya Suzuki after All-Star snub
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications