Christian McCaffrey or Breece Hall Week 1 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Fantasy football projections for RBs ahead of MNF clash

Week 1 of the 2024 fantasy football season will feature two of the best overall running backs against each other. Christian McCaffrey and Breece Hall will kick off their season on Monday Night Football when the New York Jets take on the San Francisco 49ers. Here's which of the elite backs makes for a better pick this week.

Is Christian McCaffrey a good fantasy pick in Week 1?

Christian McCaffrey

Christian McCaffrey has finished his past four full fantasy football seasons among the top three running backs. He has been one of the most consistently dominant fantasy options during his career due to his dynamic dual-threat skillset. This includes each of the past two years with the San Francisco 49ers where he finished as the RB1 and RB2.

While McCaffrey will always be toward the top of weekly fantasy football rankings, his Week 1 outlook for the 2024 season makes him riskier than usual. He has been listed as questionable with a leg injury, and while he is reportedly expected to play, it could potentially affect his performance. He also faces the New York Jets, one of the best defenses in the entire NFL.

Is Breece Hall a good fantasy pick in Week 1?

Breece Hall

Breece Hall has played through one of the worst overall offenses in the NFL during his career, but still turned in a RB7 finish last season with 1,585 scrimmage yards. With Aaron Rodgers returning for the New York Jets and potentially improving their offense, Hall's outlook appears extremely bright for the 2024 season.

Despite a difficult matchup with the 49ers' elite defense, Hall makes for an excellent starter in Week 1 lineups. He could even see an increased workload with Rodgers working his way back from an Achilles injury, so he brings plenty of upside and reliable volume this week.

Christian McCaffrey vs Breece Hall: Who should I start in Fantasy Football Week 1?

While both McCaffrey and Hall rank among the top running backs, the Jets star makes for a better pick in Week 1. He will bring more upside in a potentially improved offensive situation, despite both backs playing in difficult matchups.

McCaffrey's injury situation plays a signficant role in Hall being the preferred choice for Week 1 lineups. His questionable designation makes him riskier to trust this week due to the possibility of a reduced workload.