Tyler Warren Fantasy Outlook 2025: Should you draft Colts rookie TE this year?

Tyler Warren was one of the finest tight ends in college football last year. Now, he finds himself with the Indianapolis Colts after being drafted with the 14th pick in April.

While Warren was elite at Penn State in college, it remains to be seen if that translates to the NFL. For fantasy managers, the question is whether he will fare well as an option in fantasy football? Let's take a look.

Should you draft TE Tyler Warren in 2025?

Syndication: The Indianapolis Star - Source: Imagn

Warren is certainly worth a draft pick in 2025 and could start seeing action toward the mid to late rounds. The tight end was extremely productive in his final season with Penn State in 2024. He notched up 104 receptions for 1,233 yards and eight touchdowns.

He also rushed 26 times for 218 yards and four scores. Warren was also utilized as a passer at times. He completed three of six throws for 35 yards and a score.

Simply put, the Colts have a Swiss Army knife at their disposal at a position of need. Whoever is under center for the Colts this season will likely look the 6-foot-five, 256-pounder's way often, making him an appealing draft choice for fantasy football managers.

Tyler Warren's fantasy outlook in 2025

Syndication: The Indianapolis Star - Source: Imagn

According to Sportskeeda's Fantasy Football Simulator, Warren is projected to total 174 fantasy points in 2025 in a PPR format. We project the tight end at 57 receptions for 677 yards and four touchdowns. Warren is also projected for 117 rushing yards and two scores on the ground. This would be tremendous output for a rookie tight end.

Is Tyler Warren a good pick in fantasy football this year?

Syndication: The Indianapolis Star - Source: Imagn

The short answer is yes. Warren is a great tight end to target in drafts at a position that can often run thin. Warren is an offensive threat in multiple ways, making him prone to scoring opportunities.

The Colts desperately needed help at tight end, and Warren will likely be the starter in Week 1. Given his big frame and proven scoring ability in college, expect Warren to be a red-zone favorite for his quarterback.

Where should you draft Tyler Warren this year?

Syndication: The Indianapolis Star - Source: Imagn

Tyler Warren is currently listed as the TE11 and TE10 in standard and PPR scoring formats, respectively. He holds an ADP of 107 and 108 in those formats, respectively, according to FantasyPros. That's consistent with taking Warren in the middle rounds. Draft him with confidence, given his situation in Indianapolis and tremendous upside.