"We’ve been lied to already": Aaron Rodgers' retirement comment slammed by former Super Bowl champ

The harsh critique of Aaron Rodgers' Jets tenure has erupted, with former NFL star LeSean McCoy delivering a scathing assessment. McCoy's statement suggests deep frustration with the narrative surrounding Rodgers' arrival in New York.

LeSean "Shady" McCoy, a respected NFL veteran and Super Bowl champion, brings heavyweight credibility to his player analysis. During an appearance on "The Facility" on Tuesday, McCoy unleashed his unfiltered criticism.

"We've been lied to so much already," McCoy said. "They told us that this guy was gonna be the savior of the Jets. All they need was a quarterback, great defense. This, that in the third, and then we get here, and he's having a worse year than Zach Wilson production-wise. What did he do? A guy with this type of experience, a guy with this type of leadership, he tried to elevate the team. I didn't see that. It was chaotic the whole year."

The context of McCoy's critique stems from Rodgers' tumultuous season with the Jets. After being traded from the Green Bay Packers, Rodgers' tenure has been marked by injury and underperformance. His 2023 season lasted only four snaps before he suffered an Achilles injury, and 2024 hasn't been much better.

LeSean McCoy suggests that Aaron Rodgers should retire

Syndication: The Record - Source: Imagn

LeSean McCoy didn't hold back on his recommendation for Rodgers' future. He highlighted the Jets QB's lack of production.

"What did you do as a player? You didn't have no stats," McCoy said. "You didn't give us no winning performances."

The quarterback's own words add complexity to the situation. On "The Pat McAfee Show" on Tuesday, Rodgers admitted uncertainty about his future.

"I don't even know if I want to play yet, but New York would be my first option," Rodgers said.

Despite a challenging season with 17 touchdown passes and seven interceptions, Rodgers remains open to continuing.

Jets interim coach Jeff Ulbrich supports Aaron Rodgers, confirming he'll start against the Seahawks and describing him as the healthiest he's been in five to six weeks. The team's 3-8 record and recent leadership changes – including firing Robert Saleh and Joe Douglas – add further complications to Rodgers' future.

McCoy's final advice cuts deep.

"I think he was a phenomenal player in his time," McCoy said. "Has a great resume, MVPs and a championship. Retire yo, just retire."

As the NFL world watches, Rodgers' future hangs in a delicate balance – a testament to the unforgiving nature of professional football.