5 biggest regular-season upsets in NFL history

Sam Darnold (14) flees from Aaron Donald (99) in the historic 2020 meeting between the Jets and Rams
Sam Darnold (14) flees from Aaron Donald (99) in the historic 2020 meeting between the Jets and Rams

Upsets have dominated the 2021 NFL landscape, and Week 11's Sunday action carried on that in exhilarating ways.

The defending AFC finalists from Buffalo were embarrassed in front of their home crowd to the tune of a 26-point loss to Indianapolis. The Washington Football Team rained on Cam Newton's return parade. Sunday's biggest upset saw the woebegone Houston Texans provide major turbulence to the Tennessee Titans' AFC penthouse as they earned a shocking 22-13 win.

However, the biggest shock — at only 9.5-point underdogs, the Texans' triumph —was nowhere near the biggest upset in NFL history.

We look back on the NFL teams that overcame three-possession lines to pull off a win.

Which NFL underdogs overcame the greatest odds?

Jets defenders bring down Kenneth Davis
Jets defenders bring down Kenneth Davis

12/6/92: Kill Bills

The New York Jets were reeling as they entered the final stages of the 1992 season: the team had already lost fan favorites Jeff Lageman and Al Toon to injuries. A week prior, another defensive star, Dennis Byrd, was paralyzed after colliding with a teammate during a game in Kansas City.

To top it all off, the Jets had to square off against two-time defending (and future) AFC champions Buffalo Bills on a freezing day at Orchard Park. Buffalo were 17-point favorites at 9-3 and seemed to have the game well in hand despite a simple 10-3 lead at halftime.

But the Jets took the lead in the third quarter thanks to two scoring runs by Brad Baxter, who paced Gang Green with 98 yards on 19 carries. Buffalo tied the game in the fourth on Pete Metzelaars' one-yard scoring reception, but the Jets took the lead for good when Brian Washington took a Jim Kelly interception back 23 yards for a victorious pick-six to secure what would become the Jets' final win of the 1992 NFL season.

Brian Mitchell (30) rusn with the ball during Washington's upset win
Brian Mitchell (30) rusn with the ball during Washington's upset win

12/6/95: Revenge of the Norv

Norv Turner is often seen as the catalyst behind the Dallas Cowboys' offensive revolution in the early-to-mid 1990s. Troy Aikman certainly thought so, choosing Turner to introduce him prior to his Hall of Fame induction in 2006.

Turner, however, aligned with the ultimate Dallas opponent for parts of seven seasons: the Washington Redskins. In his second season at the helm, he guided Washington to their first season sweep of the Cowboys since 1987. The latter, held at Texas Stadium, saw the Redskins enter as 17-point underdogs as the 10-2 Cowboys were on their way to their third and final Super Bowl of the decade.

On that December afternoon, however, Washington took control thanks to two forced turnovers (including a Stanley Richard interception of Aikman) and a stretch of 17 straight points in the second half that erased a 10-7 Dallas lead. Washington would eventually prevail by a 24-17 final scoreline in a win that would kickstart a 3-1 stretch to end the season.


Also Read: How much is Troy Aikman’s Net Worth in 2021?


youtube-cover

9/18/78: One-Man Monday Night Band

Trying to earn their fourth consecutive AFC East title, the Baltimore Colts' 1978 season got off to a brutal start: they failed to score in each of their first two games (which they lost by a combined 80-point margin) and lost franchise quarterback Bert Jones to injury. The Colts were 17.5-point underdogs going into a Monday night matchup with the New England Patriots.

But the legend of Joe Washington was born that night, which also allowed the Colts to pull off one of the biggest upsets in NFL history: through a wild fourth quarter, Washington became the first player in NFL history to earn a touchdown through the air, on the ground, and via special teams. The latter-most tally came through a 90-yard kick return for a score, one that gave the Colts the lead for good in a 34-27 triumph.

The Dolphins and Patriots during the famous 2019 showdown
The Dolphins and Patriots during the famous 2019 showdown

12/29/19: Patriot Drains

As the clock slowly approached midnight on New England's Tom Brady era, the Patriots at least appeared to be assured of an early-winter staple: a first-round bye in the AFC playoffs. Eight consecutive postseasons had begun with the Patriots skipping the wild card round. With the 4-11 and 17.5-point underdog Miami Dolphins standing in their way during Week 17 action, New England fans were likely prepared to take the ensuing first week of January off.

The Dolphins, armed with 11 losses but a strong amound of fight, weren't ready to fold for their divisional bullies, however. Miami, capping off the season on a strong 5-4 note after a 2-7 start, earned their first win at Foxboro since 2008 through a game-winning touchdown from Ryan Fitzpatrick to Mike Gesicki with 24 seconds remaining. It also marked a win for new head coach Brian Flores, who capped off his debut season at the helm of the Dolphins with a win over his former employers.

Miami's unexpected triumph drastically shifted the AFC playoff picture. With New England removed from the conference penthouse, the Kansas City Chiefs swooped in to take the No. 2 seed and the bye that came with it. New England fell back to third and became victims of an upset victory for the sixth-seed Tennessee Titans. Brady's New England stay ended shortly after, as his next Super Bowl came in Tampa Bay.

The Jets defense celebrates Bryce Hall's first NFL interception
The Jets defense celebrates Bryce Hall's first NFL interception

12/20/20: California Screamin'

If any team deserved to be handed a 17.5-point underdog spread, it was the 2020 New York Jets. By the time they received such honor prior to their December game against the Los Angeles Rams, it was clear that Adam Gase's doomed two-year tenure was on its final legs. It was an era often defined by Gase's insistence that he wasn't fighting with his team and one that sent several familiar faces elsewhere.

The Jets also weren't keeping their losses close by any means (with the exception of a famous loss to the Raiders that saw defensive coordinator Gregg Williams run a blitz that allowed Las Vegas to throw deep for the winning score) and were thus seen as mere fodder for the playoff-contending Rams.

Instead, the Jets leapt out to an early 13-0 lead thanks primarily to Sam Ficken's field goals and a Ty Johnson touchdown reception from Sam Darnold. The lead ballooned to as high as 17 thanks to a one-yard scoring rush from Frank Gore. By the time the Rams were able to generate any offensive momentum, the Jets were ready to seal the deal and earned their first win of the season in their 14th attempt.

Quick Links

Edited by Piyush Bisht