"We need Max Raid education, not mushrooms": Pokemon GO player states the need of the hour

A recent Reddit post by u/TRal55 sparked a conversation among Pokemon GO players, highlighting a significant issue with the game's Max Raid mechanic. The post critiques Niantic's approach to introducing Max Raids and Gigantamax Pokemon, emphasizing the need for better player education instead of adding new in-game items like Max Mushrooms.

Reddit user u/TRal55 stated:

"We need Max Raid education, not mushrooms"

We need Max Raid education, not mushrooms byu/TRal55 inTheSilphRoad

This debate highlights a fundamental challenge — the gap between casual and experienced players in understanding and utilizing this complex mechanic.

Max Raids, exclusive to Dynamax Pokemon, is one of Pokemon GO's most visually stunning and strategically engaging features. In it, players must utilize Dynamax-specific moves such as Max Strike, Max Guard, and Max Spirit, powered by Max Particles and Pokemon Candy.

These battles, however, require a well-coordinated approach to succeed — something the community argues is not being effectively taught or encouraged by the game.

In u/TRal55's post, the author notes how the majority of players struggle with the mechanics, leading to poorly executed raids even with large lobbies. They suggest implementing an educational event or special research tasks to teach players the importance of powering up Max Moves and using the system effectively.

Instead of addressing this gap, Niantic has introduced items like Max Mushrooms, which some players see as unnecessary additions to an already resource-intensive system.

The discussion sparked several insightful comments, many of which expanded on u/TRal55's concerns.

The Reddit post by TRal55 sparked interesting discussion among Pokemon GO players (Image via Reddit)

Some players like u/Hummer77x argue that simply adding more dialogue from Professor Willow would be ignored, to which u/ThisNico proposed actionable special research tasks to familiarize players with Max Raid mechanics.

Players like u/Estrogonofe1917 and CanCalyx highlighted the exorbitant costs associated with unlocking and powering up Max Moves. For casual players, who make up a significant portion of the player base, the steep resource requirements create a barrier to participation.

Players bring up other problems that indirectly link to the subject matter (Image via Reddit)

This gap leaves many unable to prepare their Pokemon adequately, leading to ineffective raids.

Max Particles, essential for powering up Dynamax Pokemon, are tied to Power Spots — locations often inaccessible to many players.

Comment byu/TRal55 from discussion inTheSilphRoad

This further exacerbates the disparity between those who can consistently prepare and those who cannot.

A common sentiment is that Niantic introduced Gigantamax raids too early. Players need more time to learn and build their Dynamax Pokemon, as pointed out by u/MakeRickyFamous.

Comment byu/TRal55 from discussion inTheSilphRoad

A month is hardly enough to gather resources, learn strategies, and prepare viable counters, especially for those juggling other aspects of the game.

---

What are Max Raids in Pokemon GO?

Official Max Raids announcements (Image via The Pokemon Company)

The Max Raids system in Pokemon GO centers around Dynamax Pokemon and offers a unique, strategic twist on the traditional raid experience. These battles can only be accessed via Power Spots, marked on the map with a purple icon and a large "X".

At these locations, players can collect Max Particles (MP) by walking or interacting with the spots, up to a daily limit of 800 MP. These particles, along with Pokemon Candy, are vital for powering up Dynamax Pokemon and unlocking their powerful Max Moves.

Max Moves such as Max Strike, Max Guard, and Max Spirit bring dynamic gameplay elements, including protecting teammates and healing allies. However, their utility is confined to Max Raids, and their high resource cost adds a layer of complexity.

Despite these challenges, Max Raids offer exclusive rewards and a chance to catch iconic Gigantamax Pokemon, making them an appealing feature for players willing to invest in the mechanic.

---

Max Raids can potentially become one of Pokemon GO's most engaging features, offering players a fun and strategic challenge. However, the lack of adequate player education, high resource costs, and accessibility issues are holding the mechanic back.

As u/TRal55 aptly puts it — "We need Max Raid education, not mushrooms." If Niantic listens to its community and makes meaningful changes, this mechanic could transform from a source of frustration into a highlight of the game.

---

Check out our other guides related to the game:

• Ditto disguises
• Buddy Evolution Adventure Together guide
• Best Fast Attacks in the game
• Sierra counters
• Cliff counters
• Arlo counters
• Giovanni counters
• Team GO Rocket Grunts