SHARE
| Played | Barbados Tridents Won | Jamaica Tallawahs Won | Tie | No Result |
| 16 | 7 | 8 | 0 | 1 |
| Date | Winner | Won By | Venue |
| 8 September 2020 | Barbados Tridents | 7 wickets | Trinidad |
| 27 August 2020 | Barbados Tridents | 36 runs | Trinidad |
| 23 September 2019 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 5 runs | Bridgetown |
| 15 September 2019 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 4 wickets | Kingstown |
| 29 August 2018 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 5 wickets | Bridgetown |
| 22 August 2018 | Barbados Tridents | 2 runs | Lauderhill |
| 6 August 2017 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 12 runs | Lauderhill |
| 5 August 2017 | Barbados Tridents | 12 runs | Lauderhill |
| 20 July 2016 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 36 runs | Kingston |
| 11 July 2016 | No Result | - | Bridgetown |
| 11 July 2015 | Barbados Tridents | 17 runs | Kingston |
| 23 June 2015 | Barbados Tridents | 16 runs | Bridgetown |
| 10 August 2014 | Barbados Tridents | 88 runs | Basseterre |
| 3 August 2014 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 19 runs | Kingston |
| 23 August 2013 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 7 wickets | Port of Spain |
| 17 August 2013 | Jamaica Tallawahs | 6 wickets | Kingston |
*Last updated after CPL 2020
