Headed in the right direction? Grading the Philadelphia Flyers' offseason

2023 Upper Deck NHL Draft - Rounds 2-7
Keith Jones of the Philadelphia Flyers attends the 2023 NHL Draft at the Bridgestone Arena on June 29, 2023 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

After a disappointing season that saw the Philadelphia Flyers miss the playoffs and finish near the bottom of the league, the team embarked on a series of offseason moves aimed at rejuvenating their roster and revamping their approach.

Let's analyze these transactions and their potential impact on the Flyers' path to redemption.


B- - Hiring Keith Jones as the Philadelphia Flyers GM

The decision to appoint Keith Jones as General Manager reflects the Flyers' commitment to internal restructuring. While Jones brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to the role, his lack of prior managerial experience may pose challenges. This move warrants a B- grade, as it signals a willingness to embrace change but also carries an element of uncertainty.


B- - Signing Garnet Hathaway

Signing Garnet Hathaway to a two-year deal worth 2.375 million AAV demonstrates an effort to bolster the team's depth and physicality. Hathaway's grit and energy could inject a much-needed spark into the Flyers' lineup, earning this move a B- grade. However, the contract's term and value might be slightly inflated for a player of his caliber.


C - Signing Ryan Poehling

The signing of Ryan Poehling to a one-year deal worth 1.4 million AAV adds potential and depth to the Flyers' roster. Poehling's versatility and potential upside make this move a C grade. While he could provide value, the contract might still be seen as a bit of a gamble considering his previous NHL experience.


A- - Signing Marc Staal

Incorporating Marc Staal on a one-year deal worth 1.1 million AAV brings a veteran presence to the blue line. Staal's experience and leadership could prove invaluable in mentoring younger players. This signing earns an A- grade, as it provides a cost-effective solution to enhance the team's defensive stability.


B - Bringing back Cam York and Noah Cates

The Philadelphia Flyers' decision to re-sign RFAs Cam York and Noah Cates showcases a commitment to nurturing their homegrown talent. Both players have shown promise and could contribute significantly to the team's future success. This move garners a B grade, as it solidifies the team's foundation with promising young players.


A+ - Drafting Matvei Michkov

Perhaps one of the most notable achievements of the Philadelphia Flyers' offseason was their savvy draft strategy, highlighted by selecting Matvei Michkov as seventh overall. While it's true that Michkov might not make an immediate impact due to a potential delay in his arrival to the US, his exceptional skill set and potential make this a bold and forward-thinking move.

The decision to capitalize on the draft and secure a top talent earns an A+ grade, as it demonstrates a long-term vision for success.

The Philadelphia Flyers' offseason moves reflect a combination of calculated risks and forward-looking strategies. While some signings address immediate needs and could contribute positively, the appointment of Keith Jones and the draft selection of Matvei Michkov underscore the team's commitment to reshaping its future. With these moves in place, the Flyers aim to rebuild and reemerge as a competitive force in the league.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now